Opening Time:  Mon‑Fri  00:00‑23:59   Sat‑Sun 00:00‑23:59
Call now:  0086-0755-23034656

Comparing Metal Core PCB Materials

Jarnistech > Metal Core PCB > Comparing Metal Core PCB Materials
Metal Aluminum PCB

Metal core PCB technology plays a crucial role in effectively managing dissipated heat and enabling the integration of electronic components and systems with higher power densities. Different core material options, such as aluminum, copper, and iron alloys, are available to meet various design constraints and applications.

Aluminum MCPCBs offer the best value for most cost-driven commercial applications that require higher thermal conductivity than standard FR4 PCBs. They provide a cost-effective solution while still delivering improved thermal conductivity.

In cases where maximum heat transfer is critical to the functioning of the product, copper MCPCBs offer the highest performance despite their increased cost. These MCPCBs are the optimal choice when superior thermal dissipation is a priority.

For those seeking a middle ground alternative, iron alloys present a viable option. They provide a balance between performance and cost, making them suitable for applications that require intermediate thermal conductivity.

This article provides a detailed comparison between the different metal core materials used in PCBs covering properties, performance, applications, pros/cons and costs.

Aluminum Core MCPCB

Aluminum is widely regarded as the most prevalent metal base material in metal core PCBs due to its excellent combination of thermal performance, ease of fabrication, and cost-effectiveness.

Typical Properties

It possesses various typical properties that make it a favored choice:

1. Thermal Conductivity: Aluminum exhibits a high thermal conductivity of approximately 130 W/mK, enabling efficient heat dissipation from electronic components.

2. Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE): With a CTE of 23 ppm/°C, aluminum demonstrates good compatibility with the thermal expansion characteristics of electronic components, reducing the risk of mechanical stress or failure.

3. Density: Aluminum has a density of 2.7 g/cm3, ensuring lightweight construction of PCBs. This feature is particularly advantageous when weight reduction is a priority.

4. Specific Heat Capacity: With a specific heat capacity of 0.9 J/g°C, aluminum can effectively absorb and dissipate heat, contributing to enhanced thermal management.

5.Availability of Alloys: Aluminum alloys such as 6061, 5052, and 2024 are readily accessible in the market, providing designers with a range of options to meet specific requirements.

Aluminum MCPCBs Possess Key Attributes

Aluminum MCPCBs possess key attributes that make them highly suitable for numerous applications:

1. Excellent Heat Dissipation Performance: Aluminum’s high thermal conductivity enables efficient heat transfer, ensuring the longevity and reliability of electronic circuits.

2. Cost-Effectiveness: Aluminum is a cost-effective material, making it an economical choice for manufacturing metal core PCBs.

3. Lightweight: The low density of aluminum contributes to lightweight PCB construction, which is advantageous in applications where weight reduction is crucial.

4. Well-Established PCB Technology: Aluminum MCPCBs are compatible with established PCB manufacturing processes, making them easy to integrate into existing production lines.

5. Machinability: Aluminum is easily machined or punched, allowing for precise customization and efficient fabrication of PCBs.

6. Recyclable: Aluminum is a recyclable material, aligning with environmental sustainability practices.

The typical thickness range for aluminum MCPCBs is between 0.5mm and 6mm, with 1mm to 2mm being common in practice.

Aluminum MCPCBs Find Widespread Application in Various Industries

1. LED Lighting
2. Power Converters
3. Motor Drives
4. Power Supplies
5. Solar Inverters
6. Automotive Electronics

All in all, aluminum MCPCBs offer an optimal balance of thermal performance, manufacturability, and cost-effectiveness for mid-to-high power electronic circuits. The material’s superior heat dissipation capabilities, ease of fabrication, and lightweight nature make it a preferred choice for numerous applications.

Copper Core MCPCB

Copper is a highly sought-after metal base material for metal core PCBs, particularly in demanding thermal applications, due to its significantly higher thermal conductivity compared to aluminum.

Notable Properties

1. Thermal Conductivity: Copper exhibits an exceptional thermal conductivity of approximately 400 W/mK, allowing for efficient heat dissipation from electronic components.

2. Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE): With a CTE of 17 ppm/°C, copper demonstrates good compatibility with the thermal expansion characteristics of electronic components, reducing the risk of mechanical stress or failure.

3. Density: Copper has a density of 8.9 g/cm3, which provides robustness and stability to PCB constructions where added weight is not a concern.

4.Specific Heat Capacity: With a specific heat capacity of 0.39 J/g°C, copper possesses the ability to absorb and dissipate heat effectively, contributing to superior thermal management.

Benefits

Copper MCPCBs offer numerous benefits for demanding thermal applications:

1. Extremely High Thermal Conductivity: Copper’s significantly higher thermal conductivity compared to aluminum ensures optimal heat transfer, making it suitable for applications where superior thermal dissipation is critical for reliability.

2. Well-Established PCB Technology: Copper MCPCBs can be seamlessly integrated into established PCB manufacturing processes, facilitating efficient production.

3. Widely Available: Copper is readily accessible in the market, ensuring a consistent supply for manufacturing needs.

4. Compatibility with FR4 Processes: Copper MCPCBs can be fabricated using standard FR4 processes, simplifying the manufacturing approach and reducing costs.

5. Solderable and Recyclable: Copper is solderable, enabling easy assembly of components, and it is also recyclable, aligning with environmental sustainability practices.

The typical thickness range for copper MCPCBs is between 0.25mm and 4mm, with 0.5mm to 2mm being commonly employed.

Applications

Copper MCPCBs find significant application in various industries, including:

1. High Power LED Lighting
2. RF Power Amplifiers
3. Power Modules
4. Solar Microinverters
5. High-Density Computer Systems

The exceptional thermal performance of copper MCPCBs justifies their higher cost in applications where thermal dissipation is crucial for ensuring reliability.

Therefore, copper MCPCBs provide a compelling solution for demanding thermal applications, thanks to their significantly higher thermal conductivity compared to aluminum. Their excellent heat dissipation capabilities, compatibility with established PCB technology, and widespread availability make them an ideal choice for high-power electronic circuits.

Iron Alloy Core MCPCB

Iron alloys, which may contain elements such as nickel, cobalt, and aluminum, present a cost-effective alternative to copper while still offering improved thermal conductivity over aluminum in metal core PCBs. The specific properties of these alloys can vary depending on their composition:

Specific Properties

1. Thermal Conductivity: Iron alloys can provide thermal conductivity of up to 65 W/mK, surpassing the thermal performance of aluminum.

2. Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE): These alloys typically exhibit CTE values ranging from 10 to 15 ppm/°C, ensuring good compatibility with the thermal expansion characteristics of electronic components.

3. Density: The density of iron alloys falls within the range of 7 to 8 g/cm3, offering a balance of strength and weight.

4.Specific Heat Capacity: With specific heat capacities ranging from 0.44 to 0.46 J/g°C, these alloys possess the ability to absorb and dissipate heat effectively.

Benefits

The use of iron alloys in metal core PCBs offers several benefits:

1. Higher Thermal Conductivity: Iron alloys provide superior thermal conductivity compared to aluminum, enabling enhanced heat dissipation.

2. Lower Cost: These alloys are a more cost-effective option compared to copper, making them an attractive choice for applications where budget considerations are important.

3. Compatibility with FR4 Fabrication: Iron alloys can be easily fabricated using standard FR4 processes, simplifying manufacturing and reducing costs.

4. High Strength for Thin Cores: Despite their lower density, iron alloys can offer sufficient strength for thin core applications, allowing for thinner and lighter PCB designs.

The typical thickness range for iron alloy-based metal core PCBs is between 0.1mm and 3mm, with 0.2mm to 0.5mm being commonly used.

Applications

Iron alloy-based metal core PCBs find application in various industries, including:

1. LED Lighting
2. Industrial Electronics
3. Telecom Systems
4. Automotive

Iron alloys, such as iron-nickel-cobalt, provide a favorable compromise between performance and cost for intermediate thermal conductivity core materials. These alloys offer improved thermal conductivity over aluminum while maintaining cost-effectiveness, making them a suitable choice for applications where a balance between performance and affordability is essential.

Comparing Metal PCB Materials: Aluminum vs. Copper Core vs. Iron-Based

ParameterAluminumCopperIron Alloy
Thermal conductivity130 W/mK400 W/mKUp to 65 W/mK
CTE23 ppm/°C17 ppm/°C10-15 ppm/°C
Density2.7 g/cm38.9 g/cm37-8 g/cm3
Specific heat0.9 J/g°C0.39 J/g°C0.44-0.46 J/g°C
CostLowHighMedium
Common thickness1-3mm0.5-2mm0.1-0.5mm

Metal PCBs, also known as metal core PCBs (MCPCBs), are popular choices for high-power electronic applications. They provide effective heat dissipation and thermal management capabilities, ensuring the longevity and reliability of electronic components. Among the various metal PCB materials available, three common options are aluminum, copper core, and iron-based materials. Let’s compare them based on key factors:

1. Thermal Conductivity:

Copper Core: Copper has the highest thermal conductivity among the three materials, allowing it to efficiently transfer heat from electronic components.

Aluminum: Although aluminum has lower thermal conductivity than copper, it still provides adequate heat dissipation capabilities.

Iron-Based: Iron-based materials generally have lower thermal conductivity compared to copper and aluminum, making them less ideal for high-power applications.

2. Cost:

Aluminum: Aluminum is the most cost-effective option among the three materials, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious projects.

Copper Core: Copper is more expensive than aluminum but offers better thermal conductivity. It is commonly used in applications where high power and heat dissipation are critical.

Iron-Based: Iron-based materials can vary in cost, depending on the specific composition and manufacturing processes.

3. Weight:

Aluminum: Aluminum is lightweight, making it suitable for applications where weight reduction is important.

Copper Core: Copper is denser and heavier than aluminum, increasing the overall weight of the PCB.

Iron-Based: Iron-based materials can be heavier than aluminum but lighter than copper, depending on their composition.

4. Strength and Rigidity:

Aluminum: Aluminum offers good strength and rigidity, providing mechanical support to the PCB.

Copper Core: Copper is softer than aluminum but still provides satisfactory strength and rigidity.

Iron-Based: Iron-based materials can have varying degrees of strength and rigidity, depending on the specific composition. However, they are generally not as strong as aluminum or copper.

5. Corrosion Resistance:

Aluminum: Aluminum is prone to oxidation and corrosion. Proper surface treatment or coating is necessary to enhance its corrosion resistance.

Copper Core: Copper has better corrosion resistance than aluminum but can still oxidize over time. Surface treatment or coating is recommended for improved longevity.

Iron-Based: Iron-based materials are susceptible to rust and corrosion. Suitable protective coatings or treatments are necessary to prevent deterioration.

Overall, the choice of metal PCB material depends on specific application requirements such as thermal management needs, budget, weight limitations, and corrosion resistance. Copper core PCBs offer excellent thermal conductivity but are more expensive, while aluminum PCBs provide a cost-effective option with good thermal dissipation capabilities. Iron-based materials may be suitable for certain applications but generally have lower thermal conductivity and corrosion resistance.

Summary

Metal core PCB technology enables the efficient management of heat dissipation in electronic components and systems. Aluminum MCPCBs offer excellent value for cost-driven applications, while copper MCPCBs provide unmatched thermal performance at a higher cost. Iron alloys serve as a middle ground alternative. Designers must carefully evaluate their options to select the most suitable metal PCB technology that meets the specific requirements of their application.

Call us to get a free quote now